And I see no bravery, no bravery in your eyes anymore...
Every time I read something like this, a little piece of me dies inside.
On Saturday, Katie and I heard news about a fire in the nearby suburb of Naperville. Actually, it's the suburb where I grew up; where my parents still live. A mother and her two children were killed. I kinda dismissed it as it all seemed rather routine. A bi-product of my social desensitization, I'm sure.
However, yesterday, people at work were still talking about it nearly two days after I had forgotten it entirely.
This was when I learned that there was some suspicion regarding how the fire started. In fact, the son's death had been ruled a homicide.
Huh? How'd this come about, I thought.
So I started reading some news online about the event. But nothing was truly clarified until later that day when the Naperville Police Chief held a press conference (video playback requires Windows Media Player) and announced that the deaths were being ruled a double murder/suicide. Digital security video had been uncovered of the mother, Nimisha Tiwari, purchasing gasoline from a nearby station and then taking the kids to a local store to buy one toy each; their last toys ever.
Four-year-old Vakadham and 18-month-old Anaya's charred remains were found in their parents' bed alongside Nimisha's burned body. The new toys were also found in the bedroom. None of the three were killed on-scene and they were all transported to Edward Hospital in Naperville where Vakadham died. Anaya and Nimisha were then airlifted to Loyola University Medical Center in Maywood where both soon died as well.
The husband, Anand, had been in Chicago at school. He was almost immediately cleared by authorities.
Yes, the two had a troubled marriage. The police were contacted by each party after a domestic dispute. She called him domineering and abusive, both mentally and physically, accused him of using a recording device to keep tabs on her, and claimed he had opened up a separate post office box in his name. She had the courts issue an emergency restraining order in May to keep him away from her and the kids, their house, and their son's school.
He fought back saying that she was having psychological episodes that were the result of her recently diagnosed multiple sclerosis. The courts rescinded the restraining order.
Of course, the truth is only known by the two of them. So none of us truly knows who to blame in the case of their personal battles.
But to me, what it all comes down to is the children. Why did they have to be dragged into this mess? Why did they have to lose their lives as a result of this "war of the roses"?
It truly kills me to think that two parents, perceived by neighbors as normal, kind, and loving, couldn't find a way to work things out that would find the children still alive and playing with their new Dora the Explorer and Thomas the Tank Engine toys today.
And now we have a painfully distraught father who is fully cooperating with police after his wife is charged with double murder/suicide.
If he was abusive, divorce him. If divorce is not an option, run away with the children. A life on the run isn't necessarily the most favorable way to live, but you'd all be alive.
In a world where some adults would kill to be parents, we instead have parents killing kids.
That's just not right.
Rest in peace Anaya and Vakadham Tiwari and God (or whoever you pray to) help both Anand and Nimisha.
Photo courtesy of Stacey Wescott, Chicago Tribune
Flipping my iPod to shuffle yesterday on the drive home while still mentally processing all this, the first song that played was James Blunt's "No Bravery." Eerily appropriate (with some minor context shift).
Houses burnt beyond repair.
The smell of death is in the air.
A woman weeping in despair says,
He has been here.
Tracer lighting up the sky.
It's another family's turn to die.
A child afraid to even cry out says,
He has been here.
And I see no bravery,
No bravery in your eyes anymore.
Only sadness.
Something similar to this happened around here this summer. A man killed his wife and two children before killing himself. All I could think was, "I can understand being sad but to kill everyone else?"
Posted by: Dagny | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 11:58 AM
You said it exactly how I was thinking it. What a sad, horrible thing.
Posted by: sue | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 12:28 PM
I'm at a loss for words. This hits all too close to home for me right now.
Posted by: Lisa | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 03:09 PM
THIS, this INFURIATES me!! WHY, WHY, WHY do women continue to believe that staying in a bad relationship is better than being a single mom?! Good God, of course it would be hard, I can't even begin to imagine, but could it be worse than burning your child to death??!! I think not!
Posted by: Beth | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 03:16 PM
If anybody wants to commit suicide, let them by all means. But why kill two innocent kids, that too in such a painful way. I have two kids close to their age. I couldn't breath for a while when I read the story.
Posted by: Ajit | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 04:33 PM
This is a sad case and unfortunately one of many in this day and age. Especially sad when one ponders the death of true innocents. How could a parent do this and take the lives of their young children? It makes no sense and no relation to sanity.
Prayers for the repose of the innocent souls and for all those touched by this senseless tragedy.
Posted by: bogup | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 05:18 PM
That's just awful. Both that it happened in general and that people can be so...off...mentally, that this feels like their only option. Sad.
Posted by: sandra | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 06:09 PM
Horror, rage and pity. It's not a very good mixture to be feeling. And sadness....deep, deep, sadness.
Posted by: metalmom | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 06:22 PM
That is one sad story. But who knows what happens to these people when their mind snaps? These types of cases are always the saddest because the action is horrifying, but the mother must have have been in an immense amount of pain herself. Her actions were still pretty evil, despite whatever anyone can feel for her.
Posted by: Neil | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 09:29 PM
This story made my heart hurt. It is so hard for me to read about/hear about people taking their problems out on their children. It just hurts, and I don't even know them. I cant imagine ever being in a place where I thought that was my only option. I realize I am very lucky to feel that way, because apparently people sometimes do feel like that is their only choice. What a sad place that must be.
Posted by: tori | Tuesday, 14 August 2007 at 10:29 PM
Dagny, that takes a special blend of sad, mad, and crazy, doesn't it?
sue, it was not an easy post to write.
Lisa, I'm afraid to ask how close.
Beth, no matter how bad it gets, you can find ways to empower yourself to make the right decision. Or so I'd like to think. Right?
Ajit, I've been in a funk since Monday and it just gets worse as more news comes to light. Welcome aboard, by the way.
bogup, I don't think any of us can ever truly understand the motivation here, can we?
sandra, it is hard to believe, isn't it?
metalmom, not a good mixture at all.
Neil, I agree she was in pain. No question about it. But damn.
tori, I don't even want to think about how terrible life has to be to get to that point.
BTW, the media released a picture of the kids. It just got that much harder to deal with.
Posted by: kapgar | Wednesday, 15 August 2007 at 06:05 AM
That's just so awful! My father once responded to a murder/suicide house fire and he still won't talk about it to this day. Really really awful.
Posted by: Bre | Wednesday, 15 August 2007 at 06:06 AM
That can't be easy to keep inside either. I feel horrible for your dad. I know he was just doing his job, but to have that knowledge bottled up inside...
Posted by: kapgar | Wednesday, 15 August 2007 at 06:11 AM
It's things like this that make me truly ill. I am with you, I don't understand why people subject their children to their choices. Even on smaller levels.
DH and I were just discussing how a lot of our old friends and us have parted ways because we can't stand the way they treat their children - i.e. one of my "friends" drugged her kids every night with cough syrup rather than get them settled down and into bed. They seemed like good normal people, and then they had kids and... well maybe showed their true colors? It's sickening.
Posted by: Kyra | Wednesday, 15 August 2007 at 08:00 AM
Kyra, I hear about parents doing questionable things all the time. It scares me. I don't even feel right about bringing it up to them as I fall into that "you don't understand because you're not a parent" category. That excuse seems to be used a lot.
Posted by: kapgar | Wednesday, 15 August 2007 at 11:27 AM
oh wow, how horrible! I can only try [and fail miserably] to imagine what was going on in the mother's head that she would have done all that she did, gasoline, TOYS and all.. poor poor woman, to have come to that... :( And the poor husband, having to deal with the aftermath of such senselessness...
Posted by: *lynne* | Thursday, 16 August 2007 at 09:00 PM
lynne, I can't even begin to imagine.
Posted by: kapgar | Thursday, 16 August 2007 at 09:50 PM
Even after 20 days past the incident, this one is still fresh in my mind. Parents fight all the time, People talk about Nimisha' mental state and Anand' personality. In my personal opinion, blaming anand with out knowing anything is not correct. I read in many articles about Nimisha' father and brother talk about that. Always there are two sides to a coin, other side is Nimisha' Multiple sclerosis and its side effects
Posted by: harish | Tuesday, 04 September 2007 at 12:52 PM
Oh I totally agree with you. The only way in which I meant to place blame on Anand is with regard to not seeking more help for Nimisha if she was of such a deteriorated mental state. I know she didn't want help. But, if that were the case, I would have taken a semester off school to make sure she was never home alone with the kids.
Posted by: kapgar | Tuesday, 04 September 2007 at 01:59 PM